Crappy old toilet to new Compact Raritan and Holding Tank

This forum is for comments and the exchange of information relating to Trojan Boats and boating. Please do not post used parts or boats For Sale in this area. For general, non-boating topics please use our "General Discussions" section.

Note: Negative or inflammatory postings will not be tolerated.

Moderators: BeaconMarineBob, Moderator, BeaconMarineDon

Post Reply
bigralph
Registered user
Posts: 54
Joined: Sun Feb 24, 2013 8:54 pm
Location: Memphis, TN

Crappy old toilet to new Compact Raritan and Holding Tank

Post by bigralph »

One of my most hated parts of my restore and project, especially for the 6 months I lived aboard has always been the toilet. My boat had something that looked like bigger porta-potty with about 9 gal capacity that could be pumped overboard. A PO screwed up the maceator by removing a y-valve and installing a simple T and that screwed up the pump line by making it take extremely long to empty 9 galons.

Well, it's gone. I ripped it out yesterday. I'm mid project and hope to finish this week.

So, I'm putting a 24 gallon holding tank forward, beneath the v-berth. I routed sanitary hose along the port side and am installing a lockable y valve to the maceator hoping someday to take her offshore.

Anyway, my questions: 1) I'm routing the air line from the holding tank aft to the exisiting air through hull in the sink area of the head. At points the hose goes below the tank level, but the through hull is definitely above. Physics says that will still work? Right? Do I need a new through hull in the v-berth and how do I prevent stink if so? 2) used sanitary hose for the 1 1/2" toilet, but poly tubing for the air. Ok? Worst case? 3)there are now 9 unused holes in the floor of my head from the screws I removed. I'm building a short box to raise the height of my toilet? Can i simply fill these holes with 5200 and lay my box over them? Any issues?

Thanks.
comodave
Moderate User
Posts: 255
Joined: Tue Aug 16, 2011 8:07 pm
Location: Au Gres, MI

Re: Crappy old toilet to new Compact Raritan and Holding Ta

Post by comodave »

The big reason that holding tanks stink is lack of fresh air getting into the tank. The vent line(s) from the holding tank should be as large and short as possible. If the vent hose has a dip in it and you get sewage in the line, it will be trapped and the vent will not function. Sewage can slosh into the vent hose underway even if you never fill the holding tank to the top. I have discussed this issue at length with Peggy Hall who has done research and written books about it. On my previous boat the holding tank smell was horrible. Peggy recommended getting fresh air into the tank, I put in a Groco Sweettank air system. The smell was gone in 2 hours. In my F32, Peggy recommended putting in 2 vents, one on each side to allow air to flow through no matter what direction the wind is blowing. I put in 2 1" vents, maybe should have gone to 2 1 1/2" vents, but I went with 2 1". What causes the stink is anerobic bacteria. Lack of oxygen causes the anerobic bacteria to grow. Aerobic bacteria does not stink, so getting oxygen into the tank promotes the "good" bacteria. After installing the Sweettank, in 8 years, I never put any holding tank chemicals in the tank and had absolutely no stink.
Trojan has been sold
1987 President 41 DC 225 Lehmans
Au Gres, Michigan
User avatar
LandVF36
Moderate User
Posts: 436
Joined: Sun Oct 21, 2007 10:05 pm
Location: Minnesota
Contact:

Re: Crappy old toilet to new Compact Raritan and Holding Ta

Post by LandVF36 »

+1 on comments from Dave. Don't use poly vent. Use sanitation rated hose or over time, it will allow oder to leach. No dips in the line, always running up-hill and as Dave says, the larger the better.

Next thought is I had my holding tank under the front birth in my F36 and found that if I did not pump it out and left the boat sit without both gas tanks and fresh water tanks at full, water would sit on the bow. This is bad for those of use trying to prevent water getting into the cored decks. I moved the wast tank to be located below the galley / between the engine room bulkhead and the bathroom bulkhead and that fixed the standing water on the bow issue.

Mitch
Current Fleet:
2000 Carver 450 Voyager
1991 Thompson 21' Carerra Cuddy
1994 Scout 15'
2005 Caribe LCX9 dingy
1981 16' Hobicat
Former Owner - 1973 Trojan F-36 "Light and Variable"
Post Reply